Comparing Data in Google and Netlify Analytics

Avatar of Chris Coyier
Chris Coyier on

UGURUS offers elite coaching and mentorship for agency owners looking to grow. Start with the free Agency Accelerator today.

Jim Nielsen:

the datasets weren’t even close for me.

Google Analytics works by putting a client-side bit of JavaScript on your site. Netlify Analytics works by parsing server logs server-side. They are not exactly apples to apples, feature-wise. Google Analytics is, I think it’s fair to say, far more robust. You can do things like track custom events which might be very important analytics data to a site. But they both have the basics. They both want to tell you how many pageviews your homepage got, for instance.

There are two huge things that affect these numbers:

  • Client-side JavaScript is blockable and tons of people use content blockers, particularly for third-party scripts from Google. Server-side logs are not blockable.
  • Netlify doesn’t filter things out of that log, meaning bots are counted in addition to regular people visiting.

So I’d say: Netlify probably has more accurate numbers, but a bit inflated from the bots.

Also worth noting, you can do server-side Google Analytics. I’ve never seen anyone actually do it but it seems like a good idea.

One bit of advice from Jim:

Never assume too much from a single set of data. In other words, don’t draw all your data-driven insights from one basket.

Direct Link →