Feedback on football (socer) website
# June 7, 2009 at 4:46 pm
New to the css-tricks forums, but would like some feedback if possible. Good, bad or indifferent!
The site is http://www.phoenixfootballclub.com, a small amature football team in sydney australia. The site is a little short on content at the mo, but the design and layout is more or less finished.
Any feedback appreciated.
Noel# June 7, 2009 at 5:04 pm
Graphically I really like it! If I was going to be picky I would say the shield on the right – although looks great, seems not to fit in… I dunno.
Anyway, I think the only thing that lets you down a little is the typography really. Personally when I justified it I thought it looked a little better. also maybe, if possible have the date tags on the outside of the post instead of the inside, it seems a little squished in there.
And maybe you cant change this, but I for some reason I’m not liking the link colours… I think its because the grass is such a natural green, and then the links are quite unnaturally green – which is to be expected I suppose, they ain’t grass! lol
All in all, a good job dude :)# June 9, 2009 at 5:28 pm
Cheers for the kind words and opinions Rob, greatly appreciated.
I know what your saying about the badge looking out of place a little. I designed it before I had created the layout, and in turn it maybe looks a little conflicting in style to the rest of the design. Its intended to stick out, i wasn’t given many images to play with so i tried to make the club badge a prominent feature of the site.
The colours for the links come from the badge so in turn this adds up to the links looking out of place.
An improvement would perhaps be toning down the colours on the badge, or maybe bringing the green of the pitch more like the badge..Not sure, might need to work on that a bit.
Changed the parts of the pages where the dates were. As you said they were a bit cramped, so increased the padding on the paragraphs to create more space. Left the date inside as this appears throughout the site on other elements. And to be honest i thought id save the hassle and leave it as it is!
I wouldnt really go with justified text on a web page for usability sake (although white text on a black background isn’t very good either). Left aligned is easier on the eye to read, and some of the pages have longish passages of text, so i might give that a miss.
Thanks again for the feedback chief# June 10, 2009 at 1:23 am
I don’t feel that the badge is conflicting (unless you changed it since your original post), your badge is your "brand" right? Personally I feel the colors are fine (sampling from the badge is the proper technique, as you did) and the only thing I would change from a design point of view would be to fix the width of the content area with the combined width of the nav and login. Cool info on this here: http://960.gs/
I’m actually building a site for a soccer league here in Georgia . . . glad I got to see yours, for ideas. Thanks.# June 16, 2009 at 12:24 pm
I LOOOOOOOOVE your graphics. I am so jealous. I wish I could do things like that. I’m photoshop deficient. :(
I love the grass. How did you make the "grade" graphics extend past the edge of the content area? Is that some clever padding trickery?
I would love to see your stylesheet.
20 million kudos# June 17, 2009 at 8:30 am
cheers for the kind words folks, greatly appreciated.
kenD, i need to start using grids more definitely thanks for the advice. Hope you get some good ideas from the site. Would be good to see your website when you get it ready.
crashley1784, thanks alot, im definetely no photoshop expert thats for sure, just doing plenty of tutorials.
Im using negative margins with some graphics. If you use firefox with the firebug extension you can check out the styling on elements on most if not all websites. Really worth checking out for when your designing and trying to figure out how other sites have been styled.# June 23, 2009 at 7:49 pm
This reply has been reported for inappropriate content.
One of my first impressions when I first saw it was "Where is the menu"??
The graphics are great, the feel is good, the badge is neutral for me – maybe just making it slightly smaller would accomplish the right result. Back to my first impression, finding some way to make the menu more pronounced might help visitors. Aside from that great job!
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.