Constructive criticism/help needed
# October 8, 2009 at 12:08 am
Alright. This design was a request from a customer, I managed to implement some of my own ideas into the site. Please let me know what you think and give ideas on how to make it better:
Also, if anyone knows how I can implement smooth scroll into an auto overflow div, and keep the main page scrolling as it is now, but also scroll every div according to the alphabet. I will add the alphabet links below the information in each div, the user should be able to click on the first letter of the town and the inside of the div will scroll to the first town that begins with the letter they choose. What is happening now is that the page jumps to the very bottom when I attempt the above, so I removed the alphabet links completely. Any ideas are welcome. Link below:
Chris, your screencasts are helping greatly, awesome job, thank you and keep up the great work. You are awesome, man.# October 12, 2009 at 10:38 am
Sorry about the shotgun blast of criticism, but here goes: Simplify your fonts. Take those flags outta there. Bottle of bubbly and fire pic does absolutely nothing for you – you have a fireplace in the limo? $ave – seriously? Ease off on the gradients. Footer text is lost in the striped background. And that "click to print" ad simply looks terrible.
IMO, what’s missing is focus – what makes this limo service any better/different/unique than any other? The answer to that is what you have highlight. As it is now, it’s a mishmash of tired design conventions. Granted, your forms work and the rate info is there, but I think it needs some work to get to the next level. Keep at it!
Cheers!# October 13, 2009 at 8:46 pm
Thanks for your input and honesty. Do note that I also have a customer to accommodate, the photos and part of the design are there by his request whether I like it or not. As far as everything else, I will definitely listen to your advice, please re-check the site in a few days, let me know if it is any better.
Thanks.# October 19, 2009 at 1:03 am
Looking good. I’m not a fan of the striped background. Maybe tone it down a bit. Doing so would offer good contrast as well.
From a usability stand point, when i clicked the links i thought they all went to the same place till I looked harder. Since very little changes on each page they all look the same. A user doing a quick browse may not notice the change and assume the site isn’t finished. I may just be being picky about that though.
Also, you have a contact form on each page plus a contact page. I would just have the contact page, since that’s a standard anyhow, and move your right column up.
Other than some formating of the text such as alignment and color. It looks good.# October 26, 2009 at 6:17 pm
Agree with AshtonSanders. And also erase the blevel&emboss, it makes a really weird effect.
The rest its ok in my opinion. Only try not to optimize that much the menu sprite (http://www.chicagolimous.com/images/navbar-sprite.jpg), it looks pixelated, at least for me.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.