Forums

The forums ran from 2008-2020 and are now closed and viewable here as an archive.

Home Forums Other Semantically Marking Up People Directory Labels

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #33966
    Mark Root-Wiley
    Participant

    I trust that you CSS-Tricks faithful will have some thoughts on this one. I didn’t see anything in the forum on this topic:

    I’m building a people directory in WordPress (custom post type, custom fields, etc.)

    The eventual front end display ends up looking like:
    John Doe
    Position: Chief Liberal Artist
    Email: [email protected]
    Education: MFA, Hogwarts

    My question is how I should markup the labels (e.g. “Position”). I’ve never found a satisfying way nor a conversation online (stack exchange, quora, etc.) that seems definitive.

    Options include:

    • span class=”label” (boring, old, the actual element isn’t semantic)
    • dl/dt/dd (doesn’t feel right, but you should tell me if I’m wrong)
    • label (except the spec seems pretty clear that I shouldn’t use it)
    • mysterious, unlisted, holy grail answer that you should suggest

    I want to use the label element because when entering the data, that element labeled the field that is now being displayed as text, but like I say above, I don’t think that’ll fly.

    Some relevant specification stuff:

    The HTML4 spec for label says:
    “The LABEL element is used to specify labels for controls that do not have implicit labels,”

    The HTML5 spec for label says:
    “The label represents a caption in a user interface.”

    The HTML 4 spec for dl says:
    “Definition lists, created using the DL element, generally consist of a series of term/definition pairs (although definition lists may have other applications).” (That parenthetical part sure is vague!)

    The HTML5 spec for dl says:
    “The dl element represents a description list, which consists of zero or more term-description (name-value) groupings; each grouping associates one or more terms/names (the contents of dt elements) with one or more descriptions/values (the contents of dd elements).”

    (As an aside: No matter what I do, I’ll be marking up the result with the person scheme from schema.org.)

    #85193
    TheDoc
    Moderator

    Personally, I would use the definition list. The description provided by W3 is perfectly ambiguous: http://www.w3.org/wiki/HTML_lists

    “HTML5 has changed the definition of this type of list to the more general “description list” because designers and developers were all too often using description lists to mark up name/value groups that weren’t items and descriptions.”

    #85194
    wolfcry911
    Participant

    I agree with TheDoc, definition list

    #85197
    Mark Root-Wiley
    Participant

    @TheDoc, thanks for pointing that section out, I had missed it.

    I think the one thing that gives me pause is still the fact that there’s a difference between a “term” and a “label.”

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • The forum ‘Other’ is closed to new topics and replies.