It is a ridiculously huge improvement compared to their current design. The mock up is very clean and nicely designed. I notice that once I started looking at it my eyes moved around the page which is exactly what you want a design to do. The mock has a very nice flow.
The only suggestion I can offer is darkening the footer text (phone, fax and address) slightly. That information is too important to blend into the background. If you darken it a little it will pop out and it will be more noticeable to the user which is something I’m sure the company will appreciate. Don’t make it too dark though!
Great job on the new design. It’s the perfect blend of trying to maintain the same structure as the old site (helps for user navigation), while bringing it into the 21st century.
One thing I’m not too fond of, though, is having the navigation on the bottom like that. I suppose if it’s a fixed height site (which I will also have a problem with), it’s not too bad.
I’m not too sure what’s going on with the shading of the images on the right panel there though. Sort of looks weird. I’m guessing maybe something will happen on mouseover? But even so, I think they should all be nice and bright.
I do too…I can’t help but be partial to the clouds (if you’ve seen my site, you know why) :) .
Otherwise, also like the second quite a bit, but I feel its too dark. I like the texture on the third but I don’t feel the rest of the design does well with the textured look. I say go with your initial design.
Really nice job on this one.. Such a pity the client is interfering with an otherwise great layout :lol:
Always seems to be the case that the client becomes fixated on another site in the same industry, happened more time than I can recall. You have done a really nice job of catering to them in the 4th version, although the initial layout was obviously the better.
Really nice job. On a personal note i think my personal fav has to be the 3rd rendition. Almost retro, very cool.
I hope they go for v4 without trying to bend you closer to urban grace.